Difference between revisions of "Alternative Iterative Attacks (3.5e Variant Rule)"
Ghostwheel (talk | contribs) m (Undo revision 62242 by Ghostwheel (talk) Changed my mind) |
Ghostwheel (talk | contribs) m |
||
Line 11: | Line 11: | ||
To fix these issues, we have the following variant: | To fix these issues, we have the following variant: | ||
− | At +6 BAB, rather than a single attack on a full attack, one can make two attacks, both at - | + | At +6 BAB, rather than a single attack on a full attack, one can make two attacks, both at -3 to attacks (+3/+3). At +11 BAB, this penalty is lowered to -2 (+10/+10), and by another one at +16 BAB. All attacks during your turn have this penalty, even if more are gained (for example, from Flurry of Blows). |
The use of this variant actually gives a small boost in power to meleers who need to roll around 8-13 to hit an enemy at their highest attack bonus. Only when the AC of an enemy is very low (required 1-3 rolled at highest BAB) or very high (requiring 18-20 rolled at highest BAB) will the "usual" method of iterative attacks be more effective. | The use of this variant actually gives a small boost in power to meleers who need to roll around 8-13 to hit an enemy at their highest attack bonus. Only when the AC of an enemy is very low (required 1-3 rolled at highest BAB) or very high (requiring 18-20 rolled at highest BAB) will the "usual" method of iterative attacks be more effective. | ||
Line 20: | Line 20: | ||
==== Change to Fighting with Two Weapons ==== | ==== Change to Fighting with Two Weapons ==== | ||
− | When making a full-attack action with an off-hand weapon, you gain an extra attack with the off-hand weapon. You take a - | + | When making a full-attack action with an off-hand weapon, you gain an extra attack with the off-hand weapon. You take a -8 penalty to all attacks made that round. If the off-hand weapon is a Light weapon, the penalty is reduced by one. (Unarmed strikes and natural attacks are always considered Light weapons.) |
==== Changes to feats ==== | ==== Changes to feats ==== | ||
;Two-Weapon Fighting: | ;Two-Weapon Fighting: | ||
− | Replace Normal with the above description of Two-Weapon Fighting, and replace the Benefit section of the feat with the following: The penalties you take from fighting with two weapons to both your primary and off-hand is reduced by | + | Replace Normal with the above description of Two-Weapon Fighting, and replace the Benefit section of the feat with the following: The penalties you take from fighting with two weapons to both your primary and off-hand is reduced by five. |
;Improved Two-Weapon Fighting | ;Improved Two-Weapon Fighting | ||
Line 31: | Line 31: | ||
;Greater Two-Weapon Fighting | ;Greater Two-Weapon Fighting | ||
− | Replace the Benefit section of the feat with the following: The penalty to attacks from fighting with two weapons is reduced by an additional one. Thus, the penalty is reduced to -0 when fighting with a light weapon in your off-hand, or - | + | Replace the Benefit section of the feat with the following: The penalty to attacks from fighting with two weapons is reduced by an additional one. Thus, the penalty is reduced to -0 when fighting with a light weapon in your off-hand, or -1 when fighting with a one-handed weapon in your off-hand. |
==== Iterative Attacks Table ==== | ==== Iterative Attacks Table ==== | ||
Line 46: | Line 46: | ||
! Primary || Off-hand || Primary || Off-hand || Primary || Off-hand || Primary || Off-hand | ! Primary || Off-hand || Primary || Off-hand || Primary || Off-hand || Primary || Off-hand | ||
|- | |- | ||
− | | BAB +0 to +5 || +0 || - | + | | BAB +0 to +5 || +0 || -7 || -7 || -2 || -2 || — || — || — || — |
|- | |- | ||
− | | BAB +6 to +10 || - | + | | BAB +6 to +10 || -3/-3 || -10/-10 || -10 || -5/-5 || -5 || -5/-5 || -5/-5 || — || — |
|- | |- | ||
− | | BAB +11 to +15 || - | + | | BAB +11 to +15 || -2/-2 || -9/-9 || -9 || -4/-4 || -4 || -4/-4 || -4/-4 || -3/-3 || -3/-3 |
|- | |- | ||
− | | BAB +16 and higher || | + | | BAB +16 and higher || -1/-1 || -8/-8 || -8 || -3/-3 || -3 || -3/-3 || -3/-3 || -2/-2 || -2/-2 |
|} | |} | ||
*Note: This table is for a light weapon in the off-hand. Increase penalties by 2 if the off-hand attacks are made with a one-handed weapon. | *Note: This table is for a light weapon in the off-hand. Increase penalties by 2 if the off-hand attacks are made with a one-handed weapon. |
Revision as of 19:59, 13 May 2012
| |||||||||
| |||||||||
Rate this article Discuss this article |
Contents
Alternative Iterative Attacks
Iterative attacks can be confusing, where people have to roll tons of dice in the course of a round, and every penalty or bonus requires minutes to fix all the attacks.
To fix these issues, we have the following variant:
At +6 BAB, rather than a single attack on a full attack, one can make two attacks, both at -3 to attacks (+3/+3). At +11 BAB, this penalty is lowered to -2 (+10/+10), and by another one at +16 BAB. All attacks during your turn have this penalty, even if more are gained (for example, from Flurry of Blows).
The use of this variant actually gives a small boost in power to meleers who need to roll around 8-13 to hit an enemy at their highest attack bonus. Only when the AC of an enemy is very low (required 1-3 rolled at highest BAB) or very high (requiring 18-20 rolled at highest BAB) will the "usual" method of iterative attacks be more effective.
- Incidentally, the use of this variant carries with it a change to the Two-Weapon Fighting rules, as detailed below
Change to Fighting with Two Weapons
When making a full-attack action with an off-hand weapon, you gain an extra attack with the off-hand weapon. You take a -8 penalty to all attacks made that round. If the off-hand weapon is a Light weapon, the penalty is reduced by one. (Unarmed strikes and natural attacks are always considered Light weapons.)
Changes to feats
- Two-Weapon Fighting
Replace Normal with the above description of Two-Weapon Fighting, and replace the Benefit section of the feat with the following: The penalties you take from fighting with two weapons to both your primary and off-hand is reduced by five.
- Improved Two-Weapon Fighting
Replace the Benefit section of the feat with the following: When taking a full-attack action, you may take another iterative attack with your off-hand weapon in addition to the one normally taken. This iterative attack is at your highest attack bonus as normal, and is subject to the penalties of fighting with two weapons.
- Greater Two-Weapon Fighting
Replace the Benefit section of the feat with the following: The penalty to attacks from fighting with two weapons is reduced by an additional one. Thus, the penalty is reduced to -0 when fighting with a light weapon in your off-hand, or -1 when fighting with a one-handed weapon in your off-hand.
Iterative Attacks Table
BAB | Iterative Attacks | Fighting with two Weapons (no feat) | Two-Weapon Fighting | Improved Two-Weapon Fighting | Greater Two-Weapon Fighting | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Primary | Off-hand | Primary | Off-hand | Primary | Off-hand | Primary | Off-hand | ||
BAB +0 to +5 | +0 | -7 | -7 | -2 | -2 | — | — | — | — |
BAB +6 to +10 | -3/-3 | -10/-10 | -10 | -5/-5 | -5 | -5/-5 | -5/-5 | — | — |
BAB +11 to +15 | -2/-2 | -9/-9 | -9 | -4/-4 | -4 | -4/-4 | -4/-4 | -3/-3 | -3/-3 |
BAB +16 and higher | -1/-1 | -8/-8 | -8 | -3/-3 | -3 | -3/-3 | -3/-3 | -2/-2 | -2/-2 |
- Note: This table is for a light weapon in the off-hand. Increase penalties by 2 if the off-hand attacks are made with a one-handed weapon.
Back to Main Page → 3.5e Homebrew → Variant Rules